Airbnb Short-Term Rentals: 5 Reasons Why It’s NOT Welcome in HDB Flats

Ohmyhome

Ohmyhome

Updated: 28 November 2019

Airbnb is the clear alternative when you think of hotels. Not only does it allow the landlords to earn rental for short-term stays but it also enables tourists to enjoy localised experiences of a particular destination.

But, why is the Housing and Development Board (HDB) not supportive of it?

HDB, like Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA), has firm stance of not allowing short-term rentals for public housing units. HDB officially stated there is no plan to review the short-term stay rules, which aim “to pre-empt high turnover of occupants.”

Airbnb-style accommodation could affect the living environment for HDB residents. Could this be the only reason? Let’s brainstorm and deduce the possible rationale behind it.

no-airbnb-hdb-do-you-agree

Reasons Why Rules Against HDB Short-term Rentals Remain

1. HDB Flats are not for investment purposes

HDB flats are intended to provide affordable and stable housing to Singaporeans at a heavily subsidised rate. It comes with many restrictions to ensure owners are not profiting from the purchase quickly. Repurposing the HDB flat into an Airbnb would defeat its main purpose as an affordable accomodation.

2. Sustain the prices of HDB flats

You may wonder what has it got to do with the pricing of HDB. Let’s look at a scenario to illustrate one of the possible impacts.

A deluxe room in Amara Singapore costs SGD309.70 for one night. Meanwhile, a 3-room HDB unit situated directly across Amara Singapore can demand a rental of SGD 2,400 a month.

On average, the rent is only about $80 a night. Let’s say I am the owner of the flat, and I rent out my flat at $160 a night for the whole flat; I would be earning two times more.

What do you think will happen if we multiply this scenario by 1000, 10000 or even 100000 times? Investors would start buying an HDB flat at strategic locations to profit from short-term stays.

Usually, those HDB flats near tourist attractions have shorter remaining lease and typically demand a lower price as compared to those new HDB flats in the vicinity. Now, the return on investment doubles. A cheap old HDB flat does not seem like a lousy investment choice after all.

3. Ensure the survival of the hotel industry

Airbnb is a huge disruptor in the hospitality industry in many parts of the world. For the unique case of Singapore, more than 80% of Singaporeans are currently residing in HDB. Imagine the tremendous supply of HDB flats that will be competing with hotels if short-term stays are allowed.

4. Lack of community bonding

HDB aims to build cohesiveness within the community, an extension of the “Kampung” spirit from our golden days as evidenced by the different policies such as the Ethnic Integration Policy that set a maximum quota to the mixed race type residing in the blocks.

With Airbnb, this would be against the objective of building a cohesive community as many of the units would be rented to foreigners who would only stay for the short-term and not the long term.

5. Comfort and safety of long-term residents affected

Another main issue with Airbnb is that it affects the comfort and safety of the residents. Unlike private property, like condominiums, public housing are not equipped with guards on duty.
Neighbours in the same HDB estate are often familiar with one another as they would have resided there for a long time. If HDB flats were to be repurposed as Airbnb units, there would be many strangers in the neighbourhood whose background are not familiar to the long-term residents in that estate.

Cases like this significantly compromise the safety of the neighbourhood. Furthermore, tourists may not spare a thought to the neighbours since their stay is temporary and may cause disturbances in the community.

HDB has all the right to object Airbnb in HDB flats, and they are all valid. How about you – what is your take on this issue?

We answered some questions for room rental in HDB flats. If you’re looking to rent a condo in Singapore, here is a step-by-step guide for foreigners.

Sources: The Straits Times (2018), The Straits Times (2016), The Straits Times (2016)

Contributor: Leow Wei Min


Related posts:

Our finest insights you'll be looking forward to receive.

Our finest insights you'll be looking forward to receive.

Read by 200,000 Homies. Enter your best email below to join in.

Read by 200,000 Homies. Enter your best email below to join in.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Consult an expert for free!

Send us your details and we’ll be in touch within 15 min (daily 9am to 9pm GMT +8).

or

Contact us your way

Talk to us today. Available daily 9 AM to 9 PM (GMT +8)

Our finest insights you'll be looking forward to receive.

Read by 200,000 Homies. Enter your best email below to join in.

Unsubscribe anytime.

SHARE WITH YOUR FRIENDS!

Featured Blogs

Highlighting unique property views for every Singaporean

get an agent

Sell with an Agent

Dedicated experts at your service

Documentation Services

Leave the paperwork to us

do it yourself

Prefer to do-it-yourself?

Check out how our platform can help

Post a Listing for Free

Download the app and connect with buyers

RESOURCES

Ohmyhome E-Valuation

Know the value of your property in seconds!

Calculate Seller’s Stamp Duty

Find the amount payable when selling

How to Sell an HDB

A step-by-step guide to selling HDB

How to Sell my Private Property

A step-by-step guide to selling condo/landed

OHMYHOME E-VALUATION